Where Are They Now? The Shocking New Lives Of The 'I Killed My BFF' Movie Cast

Jan 09, 2026 • minute read

Contents

The 2015 Lifetime movie I Killed My BFF remains a chilling staple of the "frenemy" thriller genre, offering a dark look at a friendship that spirals into jealousy and murder, reportedly inspired by true events. Released on the Lifetime Movie Network (LMN) on October 24, 2015, the film centered on two young mothers, Shane and Heather, whose bond is shattered by attraction, betrayal, and a shocking act of violence. Today, in late 2025, fans are often curious: where did the talented cast who brought this intense story to life go next? Did they find more success in Hollywood, or did they step away from the spotlight?

This deep dive reveals the latest career moves and biographical details of the main actors—Katrina Bowden, Olivia Crocicchia, and Chris Zylka—highlighting their projects up to the current date. The film, directed by Seth Jarrett, proved to be a significant, albeit dark, chapter in the careers of its young stars, many of whom have since moved on to major film and television roles.

I Killed My BFF: Main Cast Biography and Latest Career Updates

The film’s central drama hinged on the performances of its three leads, whose careers have taken diverse and interesting paths since the 2015 premiere. We look at their backgrounds and their most recent work, including new projects released in 2024.

Katrina Bowden (as Shane Riley)

Born: September 19, 1988 (Age 37 in 2025)
Birthplace: Wyckoff, New Jersey, U.S.
Known For: Playing Cerie on the NBC sitcom 30 Rock (2006–2013) and Flo Fulton on the long-running soap opera The Bold and the Beautiful (2019–2022).
Role in I Killed My BFF: Shane Riley, a young mother whose life is turned upside down by her intense friendship with Heather.
Latest Projects (2024–2025): Bowden continues to be highly active in the film world. Her recent credits include the thriller The Unholy Trinity (2024) and the drama Dead Wrong, demonstrating her versatility across genres, from comedy to intense thrillers.

Olivia Crocicchia (as Heather Thomas)

Born: c. 1995 (Age c. 30 in 2025)
Birthplace: Connecticut, U.S.
Known For: Her long-running role as Katy Gavin, the daughter of Denis Leary's character, on the FX series Rescue Me (2004–2011).
Role in I Killed My BFF: Heather Thomas, the charismatic but volatile "best friend" whose murder becomes the central mystery of the film.
Latest Projects (2024–2025): While Crocicchia's career has shifted slightly away from the major spotlight, she has continued to take on independent film roles, including She's in Portland (2020), and remains a recognized figure from her early television success, often cited in discussions about the Lifetime movie's intense plot.

Chris Zylka (as Alex Lachan)

Born: Christopher Michael Settlemire, May 9, 1985 (Age 40 in 2025)
Birthplace: Howland Township, Ohio, U.S.
Known For: Playing Flash Thompson in The Amazing Spider-Man (2012) and Jake Armstrong in the CW series The Secret Circle. He also had a notable role as Tom Garvey in the HBO series The Leftovers.
Role in I Killed My BFF: Alex Lachan, Shane's boyfriend and the object of Heather's fatal attraction, whose involvement ignites the core conflict.
Latest Projects (2024–2025): Zylka’s career continues with roles in various genres. One of his most recent projects is the film Model House (2024), where he plays the character Thomas, proving his lasting presence in the Hollywood landscape.

The Extended Cast: Where Other Key Players Are Now

Beyond the primary trio, the supporting cast members of I Killed My BFF played crucial roles in escalating the tension and filling out the world of this intense Lifetime thriller. Their careers, too, have seen significant developments, maintaining the topical authority of the film's ensemble.

Blake Michael (Chase)

Known to many fans as Charlie Delgado from the Disney Channel Original Movie Lemonade Mouth, Blake Michael took on the role of Chase in I Killed My BFF. After his Disney days and his role in this thriller, Michael has largely transitioned his focus. While his acting credits have slowed, he has become involved in business and journalism, showcasing a diverse set of professional interests outside of traditional acting, a common path for former child stars.

Kim Baptiste (Detective Miller)

Kim Baptiste, who played Detective Miller, the investigator tasked with solving Heather’s murder, has built a strong career in both film and television. Her recent filmography is particularly fresh, with major appearances in critically acclaimed films. Baptiste's recent projects include roles in Caddo Lake (2024) and the action-comedy Hit Man (2024), alongside Glen Powell, confirming her continued momentum in the industry and her status as a working actor.

Annabel Barrett and Madeline Millar

Minor roles were also filled by rising talents like Annabel Barrett and Madeline Millar. Barrett, who has a background in theater and conservatory training, has continued to work in independent films such as Miranda Veil and Like Dogs. Madeline Millar, another entity in the ensemble, has also pursued various projects, with the film serving as a key early credit in her acting portfolio. The depth of talent in the supporting cast is a testament to the Lifetime network's ability to pull in strong performers for their original movies.

The True-Crime Connection and Lasting Impact of the Film

A key reason for the film's lasting curiosity is its claim to be "inspired by true events." This connection taps into the popular true-crime fascination, a genre that has only grown in popularity since the film's release. The movie’s plot—a friendship between two young mothers that turns deadly over a man—resonates with the dark side of human relationships, giving the fictionalized drama an unnerving edge. While the specific true story remains ambiguous, it is widely believed to be loosely based on real-life cases of "frenemy" murders that Lifetime's reality series, also titled I Killed My BFF, explored.

The film’s director, Seth Jarrett, and writers, Danny Abel and Blake Berris, crafted a narrative that maximized the suspense and emotional intensity. The high-stakes drama and the shocking ending are what truly solidified the movie's place as a memorable Lifetime thriller. The script successfully utilized the talents of its cast, particularly Katrina Bowden and Olivia Crocicchia, to portray the delicate and ultimately toxic nature of their characters' bond.

Key Takeaways on the Cast's Evolution

The careers of the I Killed My BFF cast members highlight a common trend in Hollywood: using a high-profile TV movie as a launching pad for diverse career paths. Katrina Bowden leveraged her role to transition from a long-running soap opera gig back into feature films, while Chris Zylka continues to balance major studio work with independent projects. Even actors in smaller roles, like Kim Baptiste, have seen their careers flourish with recent, high-profile 2024 releases. This ensemble, despite the film's dark subject matter, has demonstrated impressive longevity and adaptability in the entertainment industry.

For fans looking to revisit the chilling drama, I Killed My BFF (2015) remains available on various streaming platforms, allowing new viewers to discover the story and old fans to appreciate the early work of its now-established stars. The movie is a perfect example of a made-for-TV film that delivers on its promise of suspense and psychological drama, driven by a cast that has proven its enduring talent.

Where Are They Now? The Shocking New Lives of the 'I Killed My BFF' Movie Cast

Details